The red packet got smaller. The yield got bigger.
100 BAT shares paid RM78 every three months in 2015. The latest quarter: RM2.
BAT was an income stock: high profit, high dividend, a packet every quarter. Over the last 12 months it paid 49 sen a share, 84% less than the RM3.12 of 2015.
Yet on the dividend-yield ranking it sits near the top. At RM3.52 a share, its yield is 13.9%. A smaller packet and a higher yield look like a contradiction. They aren't, and the reason is in how yield is worked out.
How yield is worked out
Dividends from the last 12 months, divided by today's price.
49 sen ÷ 352 sen = 13.9%. The bottom number is today's price, not what you paid. When the price falls, the bottom gets smaller and the yield rises, without one extra sen of dividend:
BAT is both at once. In 2015 it paid RM3.12 on a RM64 share: 4.9%. Today the dividend is down 84%, the price is far lower still, and the yield is 13.9%.
So when you see a very high yield, ask first: did the dividend go up, or did the price fall faster? The 15% is calculated for someone buying today. It says nothing about people who have held for years.
Two imaginary holders, three numbers
A holder has three numbers: dividends actually received, the yield on the ranking, and whether they ended up ahead.
Many people mix the three. Here are two examples I made up, 100 shares each, with today's price of RM3.52. I'm not using them to prove BAT is bad: buying at a peak hurts anyway.
Both got a packet nearly every quarter. They bought at different yields (about 4% and 9%), and both are behind.
Why the packet shrank
Tax up, illicit packs up, then a one-off rush that makes the last 12 months look better than they are.
Tax. Cigarette tax has been RM0.40 a stick since the end of 2015: RM8 of tax on a pack of 20. Legal packs got dearer and fewer people bought. A pack of illicit cigarettes sells for about RM4 to 5, less than the tax on a legal one.
Illicit packs. In Q3 2019, 65 of every 100 packs were illicit by an industry-commissioned survey (independent academics put 2019 at about 38–53%, still very high). In 2025 the industry survey put Sabah at 77% and Sarawak at 79%. These are industry numbers; treat them as a direction, not exact counts. The chain: tax rises, legal packs get dearer, illicit packs take customers, BAT sells and earns less, it can pay less, the price falls and the yield rises.
One-offs. Uncle Chen's packets went from 78 sen (2015) to 55, then 45 in 2016. In March 2017 he got 123 sen, more than any earlier quarter. It wasn't a better business: BAT had sold its Petaling Jaya factory and land (230 jobs lost) and a special dividend was expected after the sale. Land can only be sold once.
The 39 sen. Of the 49 sen paid over the last 12 months, 39 sen came from one payment, for the last three months of 2025. Shops stocked up before the November 2025 price rise (BAT's volume that quarter was 172% higher, its best in seven years). The next quarter the stockrooms were full, and in Q1 2026 BAT made its first single-quarter loss.
The 39 sen is real, and Uncle Chen really received it. But a yield ranking adds up 12 months. It doesn't warn you that one of those payments may not come again.
Is there a next cash machine?
BAT hasn't just waited. Everything it tried so far keeps the old machine running a bit longer.
The cigarette business is the cash machine. Buying the whole company today costs about RM1.01 billion. In 2015 alone it paid out about RM0.89 billion in dividends. Since then:
- 2016–17: closed the Petaling Jaya factory and bought from other BAT group factories in the region. A lighter machine.
- 2023: launched the Vuse vape. In 2025, new rules came in and it left vaping.
- 2026: a new way of visiting shops and delivering from July, and job cuts again, about the third round in ten years.
- The parent: BAT plc says half its revenue should come from smokeless products by 2035. BAT Malaysia's own focus last year was Dunhill, and what earns the money today is still the traditional cigarette.
A real transformation is when the old machine is shrinking and a second one is already earning beside it. The honest answer on BAT Malaysia today: it tried, and the next machine hasn't appeared. If it never does, a high dividend may just be the old machine's leftovers, paid out one piece at a time. That is my view from the numbers, not a forecast.
Three questions before you trust a high yield
The score turns these three into one number.
The site gives BAT 28/100. Pillars: Business 30, Financial safety 33, Cash and dividends 25, Price 17, Risk 33. Weak points are cash and dividends and price. Use your own weights to see where it lands, or open the BAT page.
Stocks in this article
Score out of 100:80+ Strong40-79 Okay0-39 Weak
The company in this article
FAQ
Yield is the last 12 months of dividends divided by today's share price. BAT paid 49 sen over 12 months and the price is RM3.52, so 49 ÷ 352 = 13.9%. In 2015 it paid RM3.12 on a RM64 share, about 4.9%. Both moved: the dividend is down 84% and the price is down far more.
A high yield alone doesn't tell you. Three things to check: how much was paid in the latest quarter against the same quarter last year (2 sen against 5 sen), what it was paid from (normal business, asset sales or a one-off rush of sales), and whether the business is growing or shrinking (BAT's own cigarette volume fell 21.1% in the latest quarter). Our score for BAT is 28/100. This page is educational, not a buy or sell call.
Two imaginary holders, 100 shares each. One who bought at the September 2014 peak (RM7,336) has collected RM1,653 in dividends and holds shares worth RM352: -73% overall. One who bought on 31 December 2019 (RM1,508) has collected RM498 and holds RM352: -44% overall. They are examples I chose, not real accounts.
No. BAT Malaysia is not on the Shariah-compliant list.
Get new articles by email
Sources (8)
- Dividends, closing prices: Yahoo Finance, unadjusted, to 6 Nov 2026
- Q3 2026 results (profit RM2.3m, 2 sen, volume −21.1%): The Star, 29 Oct 2026
- Q1 2026 first quarterly loss RM35.2m: The Edge Malaysia; NST, May 2026. Q2 2026 profit RM10.6m: The Edge; The Star, 30 Jul 2026
- Q4 2025 profit RM121.2m, volume +172% as retailers stocked up before the Nov 2025 price rise: NST, Feb 2026; Focus Malaysia
- Excise RM0.40 a stick (RM8 a pack) since 2015, +2 sen a stick from 1 Nov 2025: RinggitPlus; display ban from 1 Apr 2025 under Act 852: Asia News Network
- Illicit share 65% in Q3 2019: Affin Hwang via The Edge Markets; independent estimate about 38–53% for 2019: Tobacco Control (2024) via CodeBlue and NST; Sabah 77.3% and Sarawak 78.8% in 2025: The Edge Malaysia
- Petaling Jaya factory closure (2016–17, 230 jobs): The Edge Markets; Vuse launch (Aug 2023) and vape exit (2025): NST, Focus Malaysia; layoffs and new sales model: FMT 31 Mar 2026, The Star 29 Oct 2026
- BAT plc's 2035 target (half of revenue from smokeless products): BAT plc announcement
Score, share price, 12-month dividend and market cap: this site's data, 15 Nov 2026. Uncle Chen and Uncle Lim are imaginary; I chose their buy dates and amounts.
Educational content, not investment advice. Do your own research, or speak to a licensed financial adviser, before investing. See About for how this site works.